KUBARK Manual: A User’s Guide to Torture? – The KUBARK manual was written by the CIA in the s as a means of standardizing interrogation techniques. This manual cannot teach anyone how to be, or become, a good Its purpose is to provide guidelines for KUBARK interrogation, and. “An environment still more subject to control, such as water-tank or iron lung, is even more effective,” the KUBARK manual concludes.
|Published (Last):||14 December 2012|
|PDF File Size:||12.90 Mb|
|ePub File Size:||9.96 Mb|
|Price:||Free* [*Free Regsitration Required]|
Moral considerations aside, the imposition of external techniques of manipulating people carries with it the grave risk of later lawsuits, adverse publicity, or other attempts to strike back.
Upon some subjects the shock of hearing their own voices unexpectedly is unnerving. He frequently projects his guilt feelings and feels that all of his failures were someone else’s fault.
He is sometimes the youngest member of a large family, the child of a middle-aged woman a so-called “change-of-life baby”. Would you care to tell me your side of the story? As children such people may have been frequently scolded or punished. Most persons have areas of guilt in their emotional topographies, and an interrogator can often chart these areas just by noting refusals to follow certain lines of questioning.
People in this category are characteristically frugal, orderly, and cold; frequently they are quite intellectual. The complexities of dealing with conscience-ridden interrogatees vary so widely from case to case that it is almost impossible to list sound general principles.
The interrogator who merely pretends, in his surface performance, to feel a given emotion or to hold a given attitude toward the source is likely to be unconvincing; the source quickly senses the deception. This site uses Akismet to reduce spam.
And a principal source of aid today is scientific findings. The desire for approval provides the interrogator with a handle. Before questioning starts, the interrogator has clearly in mind what he wants to learn, why he thinks the source has the information, how important it is, and how it can best be obtained. The New York Times ]. As an adult he continues to seek substitute parents who will care for him as his own, he feels, did not.
His primary interest, from the beginning, may be the acquisition of information about the interrogator and his service.
For the Bush administration memos, see Torture Memos. The difference is that the pressure is generated inside the interrogatee. The following questions, if asked, should be posed as soon as possible after the initial contact, while the walk-in is still under stress and before he has adjusted to a routine.
Military Training and Political Violence in the Americas. He can shift the environment abruptly. The subject may be left alone for days; and he may be returned to his cell, allowed to sleep for five minutes, and brought back to an interrogation which is conducted as though eight hours had intervened. Compulsive gamblers who find no real pleasure in winning but do find relief in losing belong to this class. Detailed interrogation ends only when 1 all useful counterintelligence information has been obtained; 2 diminishing returns and more pressing commitments compel a cessation; or 3 the base, station, [one or two words deleted] admits full or partial defeat.
If kubaro is necessary to the interrogatee it will be a waste of time to try to force him to cut the preliminaries short and get down to cases. It is helpful if B can recognize A’s signature, but not essential.
U.S. Army and CIA interrogation manuals – Wikipedia
Some interrogatees will take this change personally and tend to personalize the conflict. But the assumption of hostility — or at least the use of pressure tactics at the first encounter — may make difficult subjects even out of those who would respond to recognition of individuality and an initial assumption of good will.
A counterintelligence interrogation consists of four parts: The handling and questioning of defectors are subject to the provisions of [one or two words deleted] Directive No. He is likely to find reassuring any manifestation of concern for his well-being. The Globalization of U. One of these, planting an informant as kuubark source’s cellmate, is so well-known, especially in Communist countries, that kubarkk usefulness is impaired if not destroyed.
A fledgling or disaffected Communist or agent, for example, might be brought to confession and cooperation without the use of any external coercive forces other than the interrogation situation itself, through the above-described progression of subjective events.
The witness has kubqrk explanation. The kinds of questions asked, the methods employed, and even the goals sought may be shaped by what will happen when the end is reached.
Accusations levelled at him by the interrogator are likely to trigger such false confessions. In any case, there is bound to be some slanting of the facts unless the interrogatee redresses the balance.
The questioner should not accept a blanket negative without probing. The intelligence service which is able to bring pertinent, modern knowledge to bear upon its problems enjoys huge advantages over a service which conducts its clandestine business in eighteenth century fashion.
The aim is to enhance this effect, to disrupt radically the familiar emotional and psychological associations of the maniais.
If the subject lies, he is informed firmly and dispassionately that he has lied. So do persons who falsely confess to crimes. Any planned operational use of such persons should take into account the fact that they have no sense of loyalty to a common cause and are likely to turn aggrievedly against superiors.
Manuais KUBARK – Wikipédia, a enciclopédia livre
There is little to be gained and much to be lost by exposing the nonrelevant lies of this kind of source. This principle is especially important if the interrogatee is following his normal life, ukbark home each evening and appearing only once or twice a week for questioning, or if his bona fides remains in doubt. The time available for unilateral testing and exploitation should be calculated at the outset, with a fair regard for the rights and interests of other members of the intelligence community.
Moloney has expressed the opinion, which we may use as an example of this, that the AVH was able to get what it wanted from Cardinal Mindszenty because the Hungarian service adapted its interrogation methods to his personality.
He may be a stunt flier or circus performer who “proves” himself before crowds. It is also essential that the interrogatee know or suspect that the witness may be in possession of the incriminating information.