Marcus Luttrell’s Savior, Mohammad Gulab, Claims ‘Lone Survivor’ Got It Wrong
former Navy SEAL Marcus Luttrell and Afghan villager Mohammad Gulab. Luttrell's three SEAL brothers--Danny Dietz, Matt Axelson, and Mike Cooper says the relationship between Luttrell and Gulab resembles that of. Villager who saved 'Lone Survivor' Navy SEAL 'made up claim he didn’t face Taliban after he was manipulated by handlers in Afghanistan for financial gain' Mohammed Gulab had rescued the soldier during a fierce battle with the Taliban in northeastern Afghanistan in June Meet the real Marcus Luttrell, Mike Murphy, Matt Axelson, Danny Dietz and In assisting Luttrell, Gulab was obeying a Pashtun code of honor called Pashtunwali. . in , and a teenage son that was Melanie's from a previous relationship.
Yet Luttrell, he claims, had dropped the subject. In his statement from Buzbee, the former SEAL disputes this, saying he encouraged Gulab to stay but that he left on his own accord. Shortly before becoming aware that Gulab was making these ever-changing, and false, allegations, the Luttrells, were approached by people claiming to be acting for Gulab, who asked for substantial amounts of money. Others associated with the Lone Survivor movie and book were also approached with similar requests, at about the same time.
On the ride to the airport, Gulab spoke to Luttrell on the phone, and the American apologized for not being there, explaining that he was busy promoting the movie. Gulab had little more than the money in his pocket—and now his life was in greater danger than ever. Not long after he returned to Afghanistan, Gulab was walking along a path in the woods when the militants detonated an improvised explosive device in front of him.
During the day, Gulab slept at home, cradling a Kalashnikov. At night, he left his family and went to a secret location. The threats kept coming. One district commander, Mullah Nasrullah, was livid that his fighters had yet to kill the famous villager from Sabray.
The commander even called Gulab. The question of honor has nothing to do with his religion. Weeks earlier, after a period of silence from Luttrell, he had received the book contract from the interpreter. It not only signed away his rights to review the manuscript but also indicated he had to split the profits three ways. They accused Yousafzai of fabricating the interview, for which Gulab was outraged.
To prove it, the second person dialed Gulab into the call. Static filled the line, and then Spies heard a man speaking in a foreign language as the second individual translated. We also had a signed copy of the book contract. Later, Yousafzai reached out to Gulab and asked what had happened. The Afghan says he was on the call but claims he said: Wildes told us the Afghan had either misunderstood, that something was lost in translation or he was tragically misinformed.
Now that Gulab was back in Afghanistan, however, his options were limited. He would have to seek refuge at the U. Embassy and flee to another country. On June 24, Vocativ published the storyand it quickly went viral. When the clicks waned, however, Gulab was still in Afghanistan, still in hiding, still afraid and still angry.
But thanks to the lawyer and one of his contacts, the U. Embassy in Kabul sent a recommendation to the State Department, saying it was in the U. The year-old has spent the past two decades representing high-profile asylum seekers—Russian spies, Pakistani scientists and even contestants in Miss Universe, a beauty pageant once partly owned by Donald Trump. Gulab's lawyer, Michael Wildes, with another client, Mohammed al-Khilewi, a Saudi diplomat who sought asylum in the U.
He carries four cellphones and sometimes hires drivers and bodyguards. He soon found out why. I hope the suicide bombers or the Taliban brothers will fulfill my order. Soon, they will send you to the grave.
Two people, he said, were going to extraordinary lengths to help his client, risking not only their jobs but also their lives.
How an Afghan and a Navy SEAL became "brothers"
One of them, an Afghan friend, was shot by the Taliban for helping Gulab and still receives death threats. Even with his friends behind him, Gulab still had to wait months to leave the country for India. And once he crossed the border, Wildes worried how he would support his wife and kids. In the winter ofGulab was forced to make an agonizing decision: Flee with half his family or wait and risk another attack.
He chose the former, hoping the Taliban would leave his wife and children alone. He was attracting the Taliban…like flypaper. It was the Taliban—again—but instead of threatening his life, this caller was mocking him. Months earlier, the Americans had released five Taliban leaders from the U. In exchange, a Taliban-aligned group freed a prisoner of their own: Army Sergeant Bowe Bergdahl.
They could have worked out a similar deal with Luttrell, the caller argued. About a month later, another call came. It was one of his contacts. India had approved his travel visa. That night, Gulab and his sons packed their clothes into two small suitcases and prepared to leave the country.
As he looked at the tears in her eyes, he felt a deep sadness. Cooper Neill for Newsweek The next day, Gulab met one of his contacts, who handed him his plane tickets and several hundred dollars. Then the Afghan and his sons boarded a flight from Kabul to New Delhi. It had been nearly 10 years since he had saved Luttrell. Now, as the plane climbed into the sky, Gulab looked out the window.
He said goodbye to the mosques and government ministries, goodbye to the streets and alleyways, goodbye to the mountains and valleys. He said goodbye to his country forever.
A former interpreter for the U. The prospects for his illiterate friend and his sons were much worse. Fazilhaq found Gulab and his sons an apartment—a small room and bathroom with no kitchen—and helped them register with the U. Months later, Gulab was still waiting. His savings were gone.
Unable to make rent, he and his sons spent weeks living in the apartment or a tent, depending on what he could afford. In April, however, an Afghan friend loaned him thousands of dollars to buy his wife and three daughters plane tickets.
At first, it seemed to help, but life in Delhi was harder than it was in Afghanistan, and their apartment now felt even more crowded. Mohammad Gulab, in his apartment in Fort Worth, Texas, is struggling to support his family but is relieved that he no longer has to worry about being ambushed by the Taliban. Cooper Neill for Newsweek Months passed with no movement in his case, and Gulab was getting desperate. Once again, he borrowed money for their flights.
In late September—about nine months after he arrived in India—the U. Experts say Gulab was lucky. He is wearing a navy Six Flags winter jacket over a white salwar kameez, which stops inches above his gray dress socks and black loafers. The four of us are going to eat at an Afghan restaurant on the other side of town. At a stoplight, we watch a homeless man move from car to car, begging for change. The light turns green, and we drive off. Gulab fears a similar fate.
You can see it in his face—from the wrinkles on his forehead to the dark circles under his eyes. Not long after he moved to Fort Worth, he tried contacting Luttrell, but he never heard back. In the meantime, he eagerly started exploring his new neighborhood, playing with his children in a nearby park and shopping at Goodwill.
One of his favorite things to do was stroll through the brightly lit aisles of a local grocery store, staring at the fully stocked shelves: It all seemed remarkable for a man still learning to steer a shopping cart.
About 10 days after he got off the plane, he spoke to a friend in Kunar province. But his friend advised against it.
Not long after Gulab arrived in the U. Both the State Department and Department of Homeland Security declined to comment, citing privacy concerns. But the friend did confirm his conversation with Gulab, asking for anonymity because of the sensitivity of the matter. When Gulab heard this, he panicked. Fazilhaq tried to calm him, but Gulab felt betrayed.
I would have asked [to go to] We sit at a table near the door. Over the clangor of forks and knives, I start asking Gulab questions. Some of the other patrons stare.
Schneiderman for Newsweek After dinner, we head back to my hotel. As we park, I see a police car near the entrance. Gulab and his son seem nervous. The four of us make tea in the lobby and chat. Gulab says he appreciates the freedom he has in the U. He no longer has to sleep with a gun by his side—a strange, naked feeling. We drive to the apartment complex where he and Gulab live with hundreds of other refugees—Afghans and Syrians, Iraqis and Somalis, a smattering of Burmese.
A security guard greets us at the gate and lets us pass. The money has been helpful, the Afghan says; it allowed him to pay back some of what he borrowed while in India.
He says he signed the contract under significant stress—the Taliban was trying to kill him—and should have received a larger cut. Luttrell never took a portion of the advance, according to Robinson. But Gulab did it to himself. None, however, seem to explain the differences between what Robinson wrote and what the Afghan claims happened.
Lone Survivor True Story vs Movie - Real Marcus Luttrell, Mike Murphy
However, this part of the true story is significantly less dramatic. Luttrell was not near death when he was rescued and his heart never stopped beating. In reality, he and the Army Rangers took time to have a lengthy debriefing over tea, during which some of the villagers were present as well, including Gulab.
Eventually, they bid the villagers farewell and boarded the rescue chopper. The purpose of Operation Red Wings, which began on June 28,was first to identify Ahmad Shah, a key Taliban loyalist and leader believed to be hiding on the slopes of a mountain named Sawtalo Sar, located in the Pech District of Afghanistan's Kunar Province.
How an Afghan and a Navy SEAL became "brothers" - CBS News
Shah, who was not part of the Taliban but sought allegiance with them, rose to power in the region after the forced surrender of an ACM leader named Najmudeen in For Matthew 'Axe' Axelson top and the rest of his team, the surveillance and reconnaissance mission quickly turned into a harrowing battle, similar to what Axe Ben Foster, bottom and his teammates endure in the Lone Survivor movie.
Why was the military operation named Operation Red Wings? As we began our research into the Lone Survivor true story, it quickly became apparent that the name was often mis-stated as "Operation Redwing" and sometimes "Operation Red Wing. The training footage at the beginning of the movie is archive footage that was commissioned by the Navy. Director Peter Berg needed a way to sum up the training and selection process chronicled in Luttrell's book, which spans approximately 80 pages.
Yes, but unlike the movie, only one of them was a boy, not two. In comparing the Lone Survivor true story vs. Mike Murphy right sacrificed himself to make a call for help. He was awarded the Medal of Honor for his selfless action.
Lone Survivor (2014)
Did they take a vote on whether or not to kill the three goatherds as depicted in Luttrell's book? Mike Murphy Taylor Kitsch says in the film, contradicting Marcus Luttrell's book, in which the four SEALs are depicted taking a vote on whether to kill the three goatherds or let them go. The "vote" in the book has sparked a significant amount of controversy and debate, prompting readers to take to online blogs and forums to argue the Rules of Engagement ROE and morality in combat.
Some expressed outrage that the fate of three civilian's lives would come down to a vote, while others saw their deaths necessary for the mission and the team's survival. Murphy's father, Dan, told the Daily News in In Luttrell's book, Murphy's main argument for letting them go was to prevent the U. However, it should be noted that in making the movie, Berg had promised the families of the fallen, including the Murphys, that he would pay the utmost respect and do nothing to dishonor the memory of their loved ones.
The book also implies that the deciding vote was Luttrell's, ultimately leaving the decision up to him, something that has also been contested. What is certain is that there was a discussion during which each SEAL gave his two cents. The mission's commander, Lt. Mike Murphy, then made the final decision to let the three goatherds go, obeying the military's ROE Rules of Engagement. It is certainly possible that the book's ghostwriter, British author Patrick Robinson, who had made a name for himself in part by writing Navy SEAL fiction, could have interpreted the input of each SEAL as a "vote" instead of a discussion.
It is also likely that Lt. Murphy would put a lot of value on Luttrell's opinion, given that Luttrell had more combat experience, but in the end, as the mission's commander, the decision was ultimately Murphy's and this is in line with what the movie depicts.
Watch Luttrell stand up to an interviewer who believes there was only one right decision. Did the three goatherds alert the Taliban fighters?
Given that the Taliban fighters had set up their ambush just over an hour and a half after the goatherds were let go, there is little doubt that the goatherds informed the Taliban of the position of the four Navy SEALs. This would help to explain the quickness with which the Taliban fighters set up the ambush. It is not uncommon for the Taliban to send old men and children the goatherds into an area to pinpoint the location of U.
Rules of Engagement forbid the killing of civilians, therefore guaranteeing that the civilians will be able to return with the location of the U. Were they really ambushed by up to Taliban fighters? However, the book asserts that the Taliban fighters consisted of between "80 and armed men. The issue here is that none of the writers of these articles have actually seen the AAR report, which doesn't seem to exist online.
Most refer back to the articles of journalist and author Ed Darack, who released a competing book titled Victory Point. However, Lieutenant Michael Murphy's official Medal of Honor citation states that "between 30 and 40 enemy fighters besieged his four-member team," which is significantly lower than the Lone Survivor book.
Murphy's Summary of Action report posted on the Navy's website lists a slightly higher number but still in the same range, referring to an "enemy force of more than 50 anti-coalition militia. It stands as evidence that the number of enemy combatants was likely exaggerated for the book.
- Marcus Luttrell’s Savior, Mohammad Gulab, Claims ‘Lone Survivor’ Got It Wrong
How long did the battle last in real life? Following the ambush, the battle that ensued between the four Navy SEALs and the Taliban loyalists lasted over three hours. For the film, director Peter Berg condensed the fight into 30 sequences or segments, treating each one as a "mini film experience. According to the Lone Survivor true story, Marcus Luttrell and his three fellow comrades of SEAL Team 10 were left with no choice but to jump off the cliffs, making leaps of 20 to 30 feet in order to evade the pursuing Taliban fighters, as shown in the movie.
Director Peter Berg was given access to autopsy reports and used them to recreate the injuries sustained by the four Navy SEALs in the film. Berg also worked with the costume department to make sure that the clothing replicated the men's injuries as accurately as possible. To help with his emotional scars from Operation Red Wings, Marcus Luttrell enlisted the help of a service dog named Mr. My back's been reconstructed. My knees are blown out, my pelvis is cracked, I had maxillofacial damage, I bit my tongue in half I got shot-fragged by RPGs and grenades, eleven through-and-throughs in my quads and calves, shrapnel stickin' out of my legs and everywhere.
All the skin off my back and the back of my legs was gone. He was also shot in the back the following day, which is not shown in the movie The Daily Beast. After he was rescued, his physical wounds from Operation Red Wings slowly began to heal, but his emotional wounds ran much deeper. He did return to duty, serving in Ramadi, Iraq inonly to be forced to retire after getting his knees blown out and his spine fractured again during a raid The Daily Beast.
He had also still been plagued by his previous injuries, which he had not given enough time to heal. To help with his emotional and psychological wounds, he has since enlisted the help of a service dog that he calls Mr.
How many soldiers died during Operation Red Wings? Army Special Operations aviators who lost their lives when their MH Chinook helicopter was shot down on its way to rescue the ambushed soldiers. According to Luttrell, the deaths of Murphy, Dietz and Axe happened much like they do in the movie.
In real life, Danny Dietz died in Luttrell's arms after suffering multiple bullet wounds, with the shot that killed him striking him in the face as Luttrell was dragging him along.
This differs somewhat from the movie, which depicts Danny Dietz Emile Hirsch as still being alive when the Taliban come upon him. The shot that kills him in the film comes around the same time that Murphy Taylor Kitsch is dying on top of the rock. In the book, just after Lieutenant Mike Murphy was shot through his chest, he walked out into the open ground, away from the cliff walls which would interfere with receptionsat on a small rock and called HQ. While on the phone he was shot in the back, with the bullet exiting his chest.
However, unlike the movie, he rose to his feet and staggered into a "firestorm.
It was from there that he screamed out to Luttrell for help, but Luttrell was pinned down and badly injured. Eventually, the screaming stopped. Marcus Luttrell then reached Axe, who was sitting in a hollow and slowly dying from a massive wound to his head, among other injuries.
He told Luttrell to tell his wife Cindy that he loved her and as Marcus watched him slip away, a Russian grenade landed close to them and blew Marcus out of the hollow and over the edge of a ravine.
In the book, Marcus states that Axe "could not possibly have lived through the blast. It was well towards the end of the gunfight and I had already crawled into a crevice and buried myself. In the movie we see a severely wounded Marcus Luttrell Mark Wahlberg walking around following the battle.